News & Stories

Who Gets to Set the Terms of a Carbon Project?

Reflections from the Learning Lab on Carbon Negotiations in Nanyuki, Kenya

Participants at the Learning Lab on Carbon Negotiations in Nanyuki, Kenya. Credit: Namati

When a carbon project is proposed on community land, communities need the knowledge, collective capacity, and power to decide how to respond. This includes assessing the proposal against their own priorities, deciding whether or not the project should move forward, and, if they choose to engage, shaping decisions about its design and implementation.

Strengthening communities’ ability to make and influence these decisions was at the heart of the Learning Lab on Carbon Negotiations, held in Nanyuki, Kenya, from October 5–9, 2026. The Grassroots Justice Network brought together grassroots justice organizations from Africa, Latin America, and Asia working directly with communities facing carbon projects, from private initiatives to large jurisdictional REDD+ programs, for an in-person convening. Despite their different contexts, participants shared a commitment to ensuring communities have the agency and collective power to shape decisions affecting their territories.

Throughout the week, we followed the journey communities face when confronted with a carbon project, from understanding what is proposed and building a collective position to negotiating and maintaining influence during implementation. Two central lessons stand out.

First, communities build power by strengthening their own territorial governance and collective decision-making.

In Pirá Paraná, Colombia, carbon project developers bypassed legitimate Indigenous authorities, prompting the community to challenge the agreement and defend its right to determine the conditions for projects in its territory. This experience highlighted the importance of communities establishing their own rules for engagement, including consent protocols and territorial plans, before external actors arrive.

“For us, territory is a space that holds life, including our forests, cultures, and our own systems of governance. Territorial governance is the foundation for deciding how we protect it and the conditions any carbon project must respect.”

— José Arquímides Rodríguez, Secretary of Environment and Territory of the Pirá Paraná Indigenous Territory

ACOFOP’s experience in Guatemala showed the importance of sustaining collective decisions over time. Almost two decades of negotiations required constant communication with its member organizations to maintain unity and advance territorial rights despite uncertainty and disagreements.

These experiences also challenged assumptions about representation. A leader’s signature or a majority vote does not automatically establish legitimacy. The authority to negotiate must come from the community’s own decision-making processes and remain accountable to them.

Second, community power must translate into meaningful influence over the decisions that shape a carbon project.

In private carbon projects, communities may negotiate directly with developers over contractual commitments and project governance. Experience from Sierra Leone showed how communities can challenge proposals, request supporting evidence, and negotiate stronger terms.

In jurisdictional REDD+ programs, where many decisions are negotiated nationally, participants emphasized the importance of communities shaping program rules, participating in decision-making bodies, and determining the conditions for their participation.

Across both contexts, maintaining community influence during implementation is as important as the commitments reached through negotiation.

“Communities exercise real influence when three things align: secure land rights that give them legal standing, strong governance structures that allow collective decision-making, and clear understanding of what they are committing to. Without all three, communities are like cattle being herded into a pen. With all three, they become the ones holding the gate.”

— Dibo Duba, Assistant Researcher, Landscape Alliance

The exchange in Nanyuki showed how experiences from different regions can challenge assumptions and open new possibilities for community advocates. Above all, it reinforced a shared lesson: stronger negotiations begin with communities having the collective power to decide what happens in their territories.

Participants in the Learning Lab on Carbon Negotiations take a group photo with community members. Credit: Namati

What we are doing next: 

The next phase of the Learning Lab on Carbon Negotiations is experimentation, where participants will put their learning into practice through three complementary approaches. Participating organizations will have access to targeted support from mentors and experts who can provide technical advice and strategic guidance on specific challenges. Peer learning opportunities will allow participants to deepen discussions from Nanyuki and continue exchanging experiences. Organizations will also experiment with concrete ideas and strategies from the Lab, applying them to the challenges they face in their work with communities. Through this process, we hope to turn shared learning into practical experience that can strengthen community-led negotiations and generate lessons for others across the network.

Keep in touch


November 16, 2026 | Carlos Asúnsolo


SHARE THIS: